问 HN: AI 生成的图表
用户质疑AI生成图表的实际价值，认为其风格随意、噪音大且无用，却广泛应用于商业文件和博客中。他感到困惑，认为这些图表可能只是用于装饰，而非真正提升信息传达效果，并询问是否有其他用途或提升策略。
1 分•作者: voidhorse•大约 3 小时前
有没有人真正喜欢这些图表，或者觉得它们有实际帮助？
我发现它们太过随意（无论作者选择什么风格，它们总有一种令人不适的“繁复主义”倾向），而且噪音太大，完全没用。然而，它们却越来越多地出现在各种地方，商业文件、博客文章，你想到的都有。这让我感觉，大家似乎集体决定把商业变得像幼儿园一样，我们需要这些可爱但无用的小图表来装饰我们的产品文档或战略文件，让它们更容易被接受，对吧？我记得以前软件行业至少是半认真对待的（尽管坦白说，它一直比其他行业更随意一些）
那么问题来了，我是不是漏掉了什么？是不是我理解错了这些图表？你们在工作中会使用这些图表吗？有没有什么提示策略能提升它们的实用性？
查看原文
Does anyone genuinely like these diagrams or find them legitimately helpful?<p>I find them way too whimsical (no matter what style the authors choose, they always have a sort of off putting "maximalism" to them) and are too noisy to be of any use whatsoever, and yet they are increasingly being sprinkled everywhere, in business documents, blog posts, you name it. It makes me feel like everyone has collectively decided that business is now more like kindergarten, where we all need cutesy, useless little diagrams to jazz up our product docs or strategy papers to make them palatable, I guess? I remember when the software industry was taken at least semi-seriously (though to be fair, it's always been a little more lax than some other industries)<p>So what gives, am I missing something? Am I just not reading these right? Do you use these slop diagrams at work? Do you have prompt strategies that increase their utility?